Is COTD disappionting or no?

[tmarcus16]

I was wondering what everybody thinks of our COTD thread. Do you think it is a little disappointing or do you think its what it should be? Personally i think its a little disappointing. I would like to see a little bit more thought put into it, and provide a card review and not just a rating and whether or not the rater likes it or not. If you think its a little disappointing please tell why, whether its the lack of review or the cards that are chosen or just whatever.

[|:.NecroAngel.:|]

I have no complains for the COTD

[Dark-Magician]

i agree with marcus....

[SpitFire]

if i get the spot for it,i do reviews wen i do COTD,so........ya
um no,im fine with it,but reviews should be made.

[Darksage]

Well now that you mention that, It is starting to bug me that people just put a rating and leave.

I will put up a notice there now.

[Kidoumaru]

I usually never read the CotD thread. I never find much interesting in it. So I'll vote for "Don't look at COTD thread".

[Cyanide]

I was wondering what everybody thinks of our COTD thread. Do you think it is a little disappointing or do you think its what it should be? Personally i think its a little disappointing. I would like to see a little bit more thought put into it, and provide a card review and not just a rating and whether or not the rater likes it or not. If you think its a little disappointing please tell why, whether its the lack of review or the cards that are chosen or just whatever.
Couldn't agree more
If it were more like, Well, TMarcus knows, it would be 10x better

[Oo Bishop oO]

It is disappointing. Especially the how everyone overlooked Penalty Game.

[Atem]

I sometimes only give it a rating, because I realy don't have anything to say about the card..

[Darksage]

Penalty Game? It stinks. Your opponent has to have EXACTLY 4 cards in his/her hand to activate it. If you base your deck around it, you wont have a way to win because Penalty Game isn't a game-ending card.

[Cyanide]

What about first turn?
It has it's risks, just more so than others
I prefer Trap Dustshoot over it, as it works with Mind Crush

Though, the cold wave effect of it can be game ending

Just don't ignore some aspects of a card
Look at it from all angles

[_DC_]

I dont care I don't look at COTD thread anymore

[Darksage]

What about first turn?
It has it's risks, just more so than others
I prefer Trap Dustshoot over it, as it works with Mind Crush

Though, the cold wave effect of it can be game ending

Just don't ignore some aspects of a card
Look at it from all angles
If you draw it on the first turn your opponent has 5 cards, not 4

[Cyanide]

Thats why you set it, and play it when they've gone down to four...

[tmarcus16]

Ok guys, back to topic. ;)

[|:.NecroAngel.:|]

Well this thread has fufilled it's purpose. You have made your point that we need more reviews so from now on i'll post reviews instead of just a rating ;)

[xxxVIPERxxx]

I hate it now, i had wednesday & sunday. Somebody steals sunday off me so i wasted 3 hours looking at over 1000+ cards for no reason, no thanks to legandgenisis! I want more days! 2 more days!

[Cyanide]

No offense Viper, but the people that took your work deserve to have it
You weren't allowed into our CotD for a reason, and that reason is lack of quality
If people can do great reviews, they should be allowed to
You should be content with one day